Marriage the Second Time Around: Why We Repeat Our Mistakes

After a painful divorce, many people believe they've learned what to avoid in their next relationship. They promise themselves they’ll choose differently—someone more kind, faithful, emotionally available, or aligned with their values. Yet, the second marriage divorce rate remains higher than the first. Why? Because often, we don’t take the time to understand the unconscious patterns that drive our attraction in the first place.

The Illusion of “Doing Better Next Time”

The end of a destructive marriage can bring a mix of relief and fear. People often say, “Next time I’ll know better.” But unless they’ve done the work to truly know themselves—beyond conscious reasoning—those same destructive patterns may play out again.

It’s not uncommon for individuals to drop out of therapy once the marriage ends, believing the crisis has passed. But healing doesn't end at separation. In fact, it’s just the beginning of deeper emotional insight that can prevent replication of pain.

Denial and the Unconscious Pull

The unconscious mind plays a powerful role in mate selection. One may think they've chosen someone “better” simply because their new partner is more attractive, wealthy, or different on the surface. But if the deeper emotional template—often formed in childhood—remains unaddressed, the new relationship can mirror the dysfunction of the previous one.

For example, someone raised by a passive mother and a cheating father might unconsciously seek out partners who behave similarly. Without insight, we reenact these dynamics in pursuit of closure, power, or healing, often at our own emotional cost.

The Risk of Repetition

The truth is: you can escape a toxic marriage, but without self-awareness, you may not escape your internal blueprint. The client who continually chose unfaithful partners wasn’t “unlucky”—he was unconsciously drawn to traits that symbolised power and emotional control. Until he understood that, he remained locked in a cycle of hurt.

This doesn’t mean we’re doomed to repeat our past, but rather that true change begins with turning inward. Understanding your unconscious motivations, your emotional wounds, and your attachment style is critical in choosing a healthier, more compatible partner.

About Wise Psychic Counselling

Wise Psychic Counselling offers compassionate and insightful guidance to support your mental and emotional well-being. Our experienced team combines psychological expertise with intuitive wisdom to provide tailored counselling that helps you navigate life’s challenges, enhance personal growth, and find inner peace. Whether you're seeking clarity, support, or a deeper understanding of yourself, we're here to help you achieve a balanced and fulfilling life.

📞 Ready to take the next step? Book a session with our expert counsellors today to explore personalised support and guidance tailored to your needs.

60 Mins - Intuitive Counselling/Coaching

Book Now